(A.K.A. Non-Original Rants)

–Co-opting good stuff from all over the ‘Net and maybe some original thoughts—ΜΟΛΩΝ ΛΑΒE

________________________________________________________________________________________________

Another nail in the coffin of liberal arts

The University of Michigan’s liberal arts program apparently stresses so many new students out that they are going to have all of their first semester courses as pass or no credit.

“Our goal is to help first-year students acclimate to the demands of college and allow intrinsic motivations to guide personally meaningful academic journeys — core elements of a liberal arts and sciences education.”

The university said the program is designed to “curb the mental health crisis unfolding among college-aged individuals.” It will not include an opt-out provision.

So these students will have an entire semester basically untranscripted. The university indicates that they will keep letter grades internally for advising and financial aid, but that they won’t be on a student’s permanent academic record.

The LSA is the largest of Michigan’s 19 colleges and has approximately 19,700 undergraduate students.

Psychotherapist Jonathan Alpert criticized the approach, arguing that students need to learn how to handle ordinary academic setbacks.

“We’re raising a generation of students to believe that discomfort is dangerous,” Alpert, author of “Therapy Nation,” told Fox News Digital. “It isn’t. A bad grade can be upsetting, embarrassing and stressful. That’s not a mental health emergency. That’s college.”

It doesn’t say what happens to students who are housed in other colleges but are taking liberal arts courses as part of their core curriculum. Nor does it indicate what happens to students who, while receiving no perceivable grades, actually flunk out.

With more people calling out universities for not preparing students for the real world (and liberal arts being targeted specifically), I’d say this policy is a losing proposition on a whole lot of levels.



15 responses to “Another nail in the coffin of liberal arts”

  1. Carl Bussjaeger Avatar
    Carl Bussjaeger

    “Nor does it indicate what happens to students who, while receiving no perceivable grades, actually flunk out.”

    They’ll be given a participation trophy and told they did so well they don’t need to come back.

    Like

  2. Negative feedback is occasionally proper for the situation. Inability to ascertain the information is an indicator of poor basic education – as in butt wacked in kindergarten. That was negative feedback and appropriate behavior change was required – at least back in my day. Don’t like a sore butt, don’t do (whatever). Other behaviors cascade down from that basic origin.

    Like

  3. If I wanted to make the class totally worthless, automatically withdraw anyone not receiving a passing grade. Or better, convert the fail into a pass for study-hall.

    Like

  4. U of MI doesn’t want to lose the tuition dollars if students drop out after a semester.

    Lower division (first-years/sophomores):

    Tuition & fees: $18,346

    Living expenses: $16,246

    Books, supplies, equipment: $1,184

    Transportation: $400

    Miscellaneous/personal: $2,372

    Total budget: $38,548 or $19,274 a semester

    If 10% of freshman drop out, that’s a loss of almost $35,000,000 a year to the school.

    Like

  5. MIT has been pass/fail for freshman year since at least the 1980’s. It’s worked out pretty well for them so far.

    Like

  6. Hello, I was steered here by Joe Jackson. I liked this post and am linking to it.

    College *is* traumatic for freshmen. Many have never lived away from their parents before. Some expect to enjoy sex, booze, and drugs without the consequences–only to learn that they didn’t even enjoy the parties very much. Some have been warned about the kind of “bad company” who waste time and eat junkfood, then go to college and meet the kind who run drugs and shoot people in the back. But quite a lot of freshmen just come to college unprepared, thinking that school is where you read the textbook once and daydream through a week of review, rather than where you probably need to spend two hours preparing to get the benefit of one hour’s lecture or lab.

    So, do they need a full term of “gimme” courses and hand holding–further reducing the benefit of four years in college? Or might it be better if high schools introduced a few serious “college prep” courses, in grade twelve, to teach teenagers what studying means?

    Like

  7. Yet more proof that perceived “intelligence” and wisdom are two very different concepts. These administrators are the perfect example.

    Like

  8. That is ridiculous! Participation ‘trophy’ is right! And does NOTHING to teach them about dealing with the real world.

    Like

  9. My takeaway on their statement, “If you spend your education dollars with us you are stupid.”

    Like

  10. Or they could apply to the University, pay the money and be given their degree certificate without needing to attend any classes. I can’t think of a less stress way to pass the course, unless completing the application form is too stressful?

    Like

    1. Oh. The “DOCTOR Jill Biden” method.

      Like

  11. How PATHETIC can they get? People going to college should be WELL PREPARED due to their HIGH SCHOOL courses! Maybe some people shouldn’t go to college and just go right to work at McD’s or Waffle House! Nah – Waffle House requires more discipline than most of the little darlings could muster! I wasn’t planning to go to college so I didn’t take any “college” courses. Then a tragedy changed my plans. I had no idea about algebra or some other stuff, but got some help and managed. None of my Professors seemed the least bit concerned that hadn’t planned to be there – they just expected me to do the work! I am SO glad I had those Professors!!

    Like

  12. Now most folks should understand why obama brought all student loans back to the backs of American taxpayers. We are financing collegeloans, and having communist democrat presidents forgiving student loan debt. I paid for two children, and my spouse did two majors business, and then became a nurse. We paid for them, we didn’t get forgiven jack shite. That does not seem fair. We are paying these institutions to put out more good little communist democrats. obama might have been a dirty low down yankee liar community organizer, but he was not stupid.

    Like

  13. First semester freshman year SHOULD be a time of high stress, high demands, and should be a filter to eliminate the weak and unqualified. A slow, miserable demise is no mercy. Find out fast if you’re missing knowledge, discipline, or the ability to perform rather than waste $20K a semester for years.

    It’s long past time that we admitted that around 20 (to maybe 30)% of the general population has the ability to be educated beyond the equivalent of a 1950 high school diploma. The remainder are wasting time and resources with no benefit in sight.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *