(A.K.A. Non-Original Rants)

–Co-opting good stuff from all over the ‘Net and maybe some original thoughts—ΜΟΛΩΝ ΛΑΒE

________________________________________________________________________________________________

And the standards keep on getting lowered

 Even at CalTech–the institution that was in constant competition with MIT for the best of the best budding scientific minds.  I say was because:

Caltech drops calculus, chemistry, physics class requirements if your school doesn’t offer them, allowing you to take Khan Academy instead.

The author does make a salient point that CalTech has never before acknowledged the fact that a lot of schools do not offer advanced classes in those subjects (or even the subjects at all).  This would include small rural schools as well as urban schools.  So offering a path forward for those students could be a good thing.

Especially considering this fact

George Mason University said an alarming number of students were arriving with gaps in their math skills, and fewer students are getting into calculus — the first college-level course for some majors — and more are failing. Students who fall behind often disengage, disappearing from class.

“This is a huge issue,” Maria Emelianenko, chair of George Mason’s math department, told The Associated Press. “We’re talking about college-level pre-calculus and calculus classes, and students cannot even add one-half and one-third.”

Of course they are blaming the pandemic, and in this case it’s probably correct.  Online classes are hard, much harder than in person–a truth that’s not often spoken about.  

Especially for younger people.

It also goes to the base issue of insisting on college for all students.  Which is not the case.  Maybe this will help them find their way into the trades instead of heavy debt with a degree in 14th century French literature.



  1. Yeah well why would you want anyone to be exceptional?Sidebar:Nice try over there about the masking.He's just going to get angrier and louder every time instead of realizing and accepting that he's wrong !!!!

    Like

  2. Matthew—Exactly. Not the communist model. Re: Sidebar—I know. For some reason it just irked me. It is kind of funny though-I sent my comment yesterday mid-afternoon and it took him until today to post it and formulate an answer. A multi-comment answer, as well. Not going to continue to engage—it was funny watching him puff up like a big balloon.

    Like

  3. Yeah, I don't even bother with his bloviating about masks anymore. Don't want to provoke him into having a brain aneurysm.

    Like

  4. Not everyone has the math gene. I suspect most don't. The only reason for sending everyone to math class is to identify those who do have it on account of business and engineering need people with those skills.

    Like

  5. In the 70s, my high school (regular, not advanced) math classes were : Algebra, Algebra 2, Calculus, and Trigonometry.We could add 1/3 and 1/2 by sixth grade.My, how the mighty have fallen.I didn't know I had the math gene until I had a teacher who understood how math works, and more importantly, knew how to teach math by something other than memorization.It was like I had suddenly been handed a map.

    Like

  6. Yep, schools no longer teach writing, reading, and rithmatic… OR civics! sigh…

    Like

  7. I will not blame the schools that much. One who aspires to enroll at Cal Tech would individually show aptitude.While the schools may foster such aspirations, it begins with a spark within the individual.Especially today, one can find any body of knowledge, to any depth, complete with instruction (from complete layman to well advanced) on the internet.In this context, people today have such rich opportunities which previously were only dreamt of.

    Like

  8. Today, continuing for nigh fifty years, I regularly refer to a textbook from one of my college classes. Mathematics For Industry features challenging problems in calculus, plane geometry, and spherical geometry, plus the many applications thereof.Instruction by other not required. The subject though is the devotion one has to develop themselves in the sciences. Of course, that everyone to some degree can now play the victim, one needn't do a thing but merely exist. Someone will be by to award you for your oppression.

    Like

  9. My intro to Calculus was a tremendous textbook [for economic majors] by Bittner [I think his name was.] I found that sort of intro was exactly what I needed, even though later I went into Physics. I would recommend that kind of approach.

    Like

  10. Chuck–Some do, some don't. But I was talking to a guy today (does tile for a living) who realized that the Pythagorean theorem was so important to his work.Trailer–Had the same experience. I struggled with Algebra until a teacher stayed with me and we figured out the problem. Once we did, the world opened.NFO–Unfortunately…Henk–It's a problem.Anon 10:41pm–The information is indeed out there for those who want it.Anon 10:52pm– Those who are taught to play the victim can never know the joy of discovery.Avraham–Glad you found the one that put you on the path!

    Like

  11. Yeah well why would you want anyone to be exceptional?Sidebar:Nice try over there about the masking.He's just going to get angrier and louder every time instead of realizing and accepting that he's wrong !!!!

    Like

  12. Matthew—Exactly. Not the communist model. Re: Sidebar—I know. For some reason it just irked me. It is kind of funny though-I sent my comment yesterday mid-afternoon and it took him until today to post it and formulate an answer. A multi-comment answer, as well. Not going to continue to engage—it was funny watching him puff up like a big balloon.

    Like

  13. Yeah, I don't even bother with his bloviating about masks anymore. Don't want to provoke him into having a brain aneurysm.

    Like

  14. Not everyone has the math gene. I suspect most don't. The only reason for sending everyone to math class is to identify those who do have it on account of business and engineering need people with those skills.

    Like

  15. In the 70s, my high school (regular, not advanced) math classes were : Algebra, Algebra 2, Calculus, and Trigonometry.We could add 1/3 and 1/2 by sixth grade.My, how the mighty have fallen.I didn't know I had the math gene until I had a teacher who understood how math works, and more importantly, knew how to teach math by something other than memorization.It was like I had suddenly been handed a map.

    Like

  16. Yep, schools no longer teach writing, reading, and rithmatic… OR civics! sigh…

    Like

  17. I will not blame the schools that much. One who aspires to enroll at Cal Tech would individually show aptitude.While the schools may foster such aspirations, it begins with a spark within the individual.Especially today, one can find any body of knowledge, to any depth, complete with instruction (from complete layman to well advanced) on the internet.In this context, people today have such rich opportunities which previously were only dreamt of.

    Like

  18. Today, continuing for nigh fifty years, I regularly refer to a textbook from one of my college classes. Mathematics For Industry features challenging problems in calculus, plane geometry, and spherical geometry, plus the many applications thereof.Instruction by other not required. The subject though is the devotion one has to develop themselves in the sciences. Of course, that everyone to some degree can now play the victim, one needn't do a thing but merely exist. Someone will be by to award you for your oppression.

    Like

  19. My intro to Calculus was a tremendous textbook [for economic majors] by Bittner [I think his name was.] I found that sort of intro was exactly what I needed, even though later I went into Physics. I would recommend that kind of approach.

    Like

  20. Chuck–Some do, some don't. But I was talking to a guy today (does tile for a living) who realized that the Pythagorean theorem was so important to his work.Trailer–Had the same experience. I struggled with Algebra until a teacher stayed with me and we figured out the problem. Once we did, the world opened.NFO–Unfortunately…Henk–It's a problem.Anon 10:41pm–The information is indeed out there for those who want it.Anon 10:52pm– Those who are taught to play the victim can never know the joy of discovery.Avraham–Glad you found the one that put you on the path!

    Like

Leave a Reply to Anonymous Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *